Link
The latest Eurozone PMIs confirmed a stabilization of activity, thanks in particular to services, although the zone's economy is stagnating overall. But they also showed major differences between countries. Germany's IFO index for February confirmed the country's persistent weakness. Indeed, the index remained stable at a very low level, well below the historical average. Obviously, the weakness of industrial activity is weighing even more heavily on the country, especially as one of its key export markets is China, where the economic dynamic remains unfavorable to imports.
The only good news is that business expectations rebounded very slightly over the month, but this is scant consolation. It will surely take a much more marked cyclical change, particularly in terms of external demand, for a more noticeable upturn in activity, particularly in manufacturing, to take shape.
Fig.1 Germany: The IFO index remains at a historically low level, even though expectations are edging upwards.
-IFO, business climate, Index
-Current situation, Index
-Anticipations, Index
Amplifying this message of gloom, the more detailed data on demand's contribution to the fall in GDP in 4Q23 (-0.3%) showed that it was indeed investment that floundered at the end of last year, with a -1.9% decline over the quarter, the biggest drop in 2 years.
The good news came from consumption, which held up well, rebounding in the final quarter after stagnating in the previous quarter. At the same time, public spending prevented a more pronounced contraction in GDP. On this point, it remains to be seen how the ruling coalition, under the leadership of O. Scholz, can do more to support activity, including by accelerating strategic spending on the energy transition and its military spending.
Fig.2 Germany: The sharp drop in investment made a major contribution to the contraction in activity.
-GDP
-Consumption
-Government expenditure
-investment
IAt the same time, we still believe that, given the weakness of growth in the zone, inflationary pressures should continue to ease, allowing the ECB to loosen monetary policy. Nevertheless, the persistence of tight labor markets raises real questions about the dynamics of disinflation.
Admittedly, the latest statistics on wage dynamics published by the ECB showed a dip in wage growth in 4Q23, but this was slight and will need to be confirmed to reassure the ECB before interest rates can be cut.
As is well known, the debate is tense among the members of the Governing Council, between those who think that we shouldn't wait too long to start easing monetary policy and those who want to be more patient to ensure that the trend is indeed moving in the direction of convergence of inflation towards the 2% target.
To fuel the debate, the results of the ECB's household survey on inflation expectations for January gave a not necessarily reassuring message. Expectations for the next 1 year have risen to 3.3%, but this statistic is fairly volatile and sensitive to energy prices. 3-year expectations are no longer falling, and are stagnating at 2.5%.
This indicator is not necessarily the one that will dominate the debate, but it does send a message of caution to central bankers, and is to the advantage of those who want to be more patient. Furthermore, we note that there are different dynamics between countries, where disinflation is maintaining its downward trend, as in Italy and Spain, while in Germany it is accelerating slightly for medium-term expectations.
Nevertheless, we still expect monetary policy to ease in 2Q24.
Fig.3 Euro-Zone: ECB survey of household inflation expectations for January shows 3-year forecasts stagnating at 2.5%.
-3-year forecast
-1-year forecast